Files
bookhoard/docs/contract_pins.md
T
John O'Keefe 7d698ea0d8 fix(annotations): bookmark and note PUTs land through the sync service (LWW by id)
H3 census bugs #2 and #3: both web PUTs used plain queries that
bypassed the sync-aware layer entirely — no LWW, no source bookkeeping,
and locator fields the client couldn't even send. The highlight PUT was
the only one already routed (via HighlightID); the other two now mirror
it:

- SaveBookmarkRequest gains BookmarkID, SaveNoteRequest gains NoteID:
  id-targeted resolution reads the exact row, verifies ownership,
  LWWs under its stored dedup key, and resurrects tombstones when the
  edit is newer (same doctrine and comment structure as the highlight
  path).
- Fields the PUT omits are coalesced from the stored row before the
  full-column sync update — the legacy web PUT sends only
  title/notes/position, and zeroing cfi/percentage/page on every edit
  would have been data loss. Verified both directions by
  TestH3_BookmarkPUTPreservesLocators (omitted survives, explicit
  lands).
- The bookmark PUT's wire DTO gains the create endpoint's locator keys
  as optional fields (documented additive request keys in
  contract_pins.md); the note PUT keeps its content+position wire.

UpdateMediaBookmark/UpdateMediaNote plain queries are now uncalled
(the generated queries stay until the H4 query sweep).
2026-10-17 15:53:12 -04:00

7.0 KiB

Wire-contract pins (hardening batches)

These are the response SHAPES (JSON key sets, not values) frozen by the TestContractPin_* suite in cmd/server/tests/contract_pins_test.go (batch H0). The plan they serve is ~/.opencode/plan/hardening-canonical-types.md.

Rules

  1. Frozen: no existing response key may be RENAMED or REMOVED on any endpoint below (JSON or KOReader/Kobo adapters). Requests are frozen too — no parsing changes.
  2. Additive keys are allowed and expected — but a batch must widen the allowed slice in the test AND record the addition in the changelog below, in the same commit.
  3. KOReader / Kobo / progress surfaces are the hard freeze: the KOReader plugin is an external client whose handlers keep response shapes byte-identical (only their internals may route through shared funnels).
  4. A behavior fix that would require narrowing or REMOVING a pinned key needs the user's explicit sign-off before the pin is touched — a pin freezing buggy behavior is a known-bugs ledger, not a license.

Pinned surfaces

Test Surface Shape
ProgressWeb GET /api/media-items/:id/progress (percentage-only write) flat map: id, media_item_id, user_id, current_page, total_pages, last_read_at, percentage, character_offset, epubcfi, chapter, chapter_progress, format_group, total_characters, chapter_count, last_sync_device, last_sync_source, last_sync_timestamp
… conditional bolt-ons context_text (when stored valid); css_selector, anchor_href, char_offset, rewritten epubcfi (when the anchor verify path fires)
PUT /api/media-items/:id/progress response database.ReadingProgress JSON (25 keys incl. audio_offset_seconds, viewport/zoom/scroll/panel/reading_mode)
GET with no rows exactly {current_page, total_pages}
KOReaderProgressPush POST /api/sync/koreader/progress (immediate, 202) sync_status, books_synced, book_results[]?{sha256, book_uuid, synced}, conflicts[]?{book_uuid, conflict_type, device_progress, server_progress, resolution}, timestamp, device_updated
KOReaderProgressPull GET /api/sync/koreader/metadata/:uuid uuid, sha256?, title, authors, progress{percentage + optional character/epubcfi/koreader_xpointer/chapter/chapter_progress/page/total_pages}, annotations{highlights?, notes?, bookmarks?, deleted_highlights?, deleted_bookmarks?}, last_sync
KOReaderLibrary GET /api/sync/koreader/library library_sync[]{uuid, sha256?, title, author, content_type, percent_read, pages_remaining?, bookmark_count, last_modified}, total_books, last_sync
KOReaderBookmarksPush POST /api/sync/koreader/bookmarks sync_status, bookmarks_synced, notes_synced, highlights_synced, total_synced, timestamp
KoboInitialization GET /api/sync/kobo/:token/v1/initialization library_sync[]{ContentId, ContentType, Title, Author, PercentRead, PagesRemaining?, BookmarkCount, LastModified, EntitlementId, Revision, MimeType, FileSize, Categories?, BookhoardUUID?}, total_books, last_sync
KoboMarkupSync POST /api/sync/kobo/:token/markup Status, MarkupsSynced, BookmarksSynced, DeletedAnnotations?
KoboSyncFromServer POST /api/sync/kobo/:token/sync-from-server BooksSynced, BookmarksSent, HighlightsSent
CollectionsJSON GET /api/collections/:id (all 4 branches) envelope id, user_id, name, description, color, icon, auto_assign_rules, view_settings, books[], book_count, is_smart, created_at; books = BookInfo
POST /api/collections/preview bare {items: BookInfo[]}
SeriesJSON GET /api/series/books?name=&library_id= {name, library_id, books: BookInfo[], total}
SearchJSON GET /api/media-items/search?q=&library_id= top-level array of SearchMediaItemsUnifiedRow (47 keys)
DashboardSections GET /api/dashboard/sections {sections[]: {id, collection_id, is_system, title, description, icon, items: BookInfo[], view_all_url, priority}}
MediaListBothBranches GET /api/media-items (unscoped) {data: [38-key resolved map]} (intentionally divergent from the scoped branch until the row-shape collapse batch)
GET /api/media-items?library_id=&sort= {data: [raw ListMediaItemsSortedRow, 70 sqlc keys]}
SSRPages /bookshelf, /collections, /collections/:id, /series, /series/detail, /tags/detail 200 + stable title/substring markers

BookInfo (every card surface): media_item_id, title, author, cover_image_path, has_conflict, format_group, badge.

Changelog (additive keys per batch)

  • H0 (initial pin) — the shapes above, captured on the unmodified tree at commit b4ae423.
  • H1 (progress canonicalization) — GET /api/media-items/:id/progress Whitelisted ADDITIVE keys (fields the GetUniversalProgressRow already carries, now surfaced by the shared row serializer): audio_offset_seconds, reading_mode, viewport_x, viewport_y, zoom_level, scroll_position_x, scroll_position_y, panel_number. No key removed or renamed; the no-rows and PUT-response shapes are untouched. The web PUT binds SaveProgressRequest directly — its parse set for existing clients is IDENTICAL to the old DTO (verified against web/src reader.ts:3113-3143 and audio.ts:518-520); keys the web never sent (viewport_x/y, panel_number) merely become honor-able. All other pins unchanged.
  • H3-prep (web annotation CRUD freeze) — NEW pinned surfaces, captured pre-refactor per the pin-first doctrine: POST/PUT/DELETE /api/media-items/:id/{notes,highlights,bookmarks} — create 201 / update 200 / delete 204, response bodies are the full sqlc row models (MediaNotes 19 keys, MediaBookmarks 20 keys, MediaHighlights 27 keys — listed in contract_pins_test.go). No keys removed; nothing was pinned here before. Capturing these immediately caught a LIVE server bug: applyNoteLWW omitted UserID from its UpdateMediaNoteForSync params, so every dedup-hit note re-save (same content+position ⇒ same key) returned 500 ("update note: no rows in result set") — the LWW update could never land. Fixed in the same commit (server-side fix, freely allowed); the pins are its regression net.
  • H3 (PUT fixes routed through the sync service) — PUT /api/media-items/:id/bookmarks/:bookmarkId now parses ADDITIONAL optional request keys mirroring its create sibling: cfi_position, page_number, chapter_number, percentage, chapter_reference (all zero-value-preserving: omitted keys coalesce with the stored row inside the service, so legacy clients that send only title/notes/position keep every stored locator — verified by TestH3_BookmarkPUTPreservesLocators). The PUT lands as an id-targeted LWW edit under the row's stored dedup key (BookmarkID/NoteID mirror SaveHighlightRequest.HighlightID), so last_modified_source / last_modified_at are now maintained. Note PUT unchanged on the wire (content+position) but routed through the service the same way. Response shapes unchanged (same row models — pins green).